Former National Security boss, Brigadier General Nunoo Mensah, has described as unnecessary, the hiring of three South African ex-policemen to train bodyguards for the New Patriotic Party.
He contended there are capable security experts in the country who could offer such training as opposed to bringing into the country expatriates.
“I think we should have faith in ourselves and believe in ourselves, and I know we are capable of training our own, rather than bring in South Africans to come and train us which I find totally unnecessary,” he said on 3FM 92.7 Thursday morning.
He said there is nothing that the expatriate can do which our local experts cannot do saying ““I sit down here and I don’t know what a white man can do that I can’t so why do we create the impression that we don’t believe in ourselves”.
Mr. Nunoo Mensah recalled how Ghana’s first president, Dr Kwame Nkrumah, marshaled Ghanaians to help Zimbabwe and others fight their wars, adding “so if we could do these things on our own some years back, then I don’t see the need for us to bring in foreigners to assist us”.
The three South African – 54-year-old Major Ahmed Shaik Hazis (Rtd.), 39-year–old WO/ Denver Dwayhe Naidu (Rtd.) and 45-year-old Captain Mlungiseleli Jokani (Rtd.), were picked up on Sunday March 20, 2016 at El Capitano Hotel in Agona Duakwa in the Central Region have since last Tuesday been deported.
Founder and Leader of the National Democratic Party (NDP) Nana Kondau Agyemang-Rawlings says the level of corruption in the country is akin to visiting violence on Ghanaians.
“It is not when somebody even attacks you or fights you that is equal to violence,” she opines.
“Violence is when you have violated us. When we have given you our mandate to run a country efficiently and effectively and you are able to disrupt the lives of Ghanaians.”
The former First Lady contends that the mantra of the current government – Changing Lives – holds only in the negative sense.
“You can tell us you are changing our lives,” she said.
“Yes, indeed you are changing our lives but not for the better.”
Mrs Rawlings made these remarks during the Greater Accra Regional Congress of the NDP in Accra.
Executives called for massive support for victory in the 2016 elections.
Nana Konadu urged opinion leaders and intellectuals to speak up against the ills in the country before things deteriorate.
Terrorist group Boko Haram has tormented north-east Nigeria for years
Ghana is not likely to be a central target for terrorists, reports the Economic Intelligence Unit, but its close ties with the West and significant expatriate population in Accra may draw the attention of extremists.
This was contained in the Unit’s report of February 2016.
The report also predicts victory for the New Patriotic Party (NPP) in the 2016 polls, adducing that: “There is little time for Mr Mahama and the NDC to turn the economy around before the November 2016 presidential and legislative elections.”
Read full report below:
Outlook for 2016-20 Political stability
Ghana will continue to enjoy an enviable level of political stability in the coming five years, backed by its robust democracy. This does not mean, however, that it will be without significant tensions at some points. Public resentment at slow economic growth by historical standards, electricity shortages, high inflation and currency depreciation is likely to result in public protests, as have happened sporadically over the past year.
The president, John Mahama, and the National Democratic Congress (NDC) government will bear the brunt of the blame for the situation, with the opposition New Patriotic Party (NPP) attempting to act as a focus for disenchanted Ghanaians to rally around, knowing that attacking the government’s economic record represents its best chance of taking power at the elections set for November 2016.
In extreme cases public anger can snowball into a popular uprising. However, such a level of instability is unlikely in Ghana, where democracy is firmly established; the entrenchment of the democratic process is the most powerful factor in preventing popular unrest expanding to the point that it threatens the political structure as a whole. Nonetheless, although Ghana’s democracy will shield it from a breakdown in political stability, election-related tensions, particularly if close results are disputed by the losing side, are likely to result in outbreaks of unrest.
The NPP goes into the election period unhappy that its demands for a new electoral roll have been rejected by the Electoral Commission in favour of a cleaning¬up of the current register— which the NPP claim is biased towards the NDC. A disputed election would be decided by the courts, as happened in 2012. At that time all sides accepted the verdict.
However, in 2015 the judiciary was hit by major corruption allegations. A lack of trust in the judiciary would make it more likely that any 2016 election case verdict is not accepted, increasing the risk of instability. However, if, as seems likely at present, there is a transparent investigation into the corruption allegations that punishes those guilty of wrongdoing, then trust should be improved enough for any 2016 election challenges to be handled without triggering instability.
After a fraught 2016 election period, the threat of instability will recede during 2017 19 as better economic performance helps to ease frustrations, before another spike in tensions ahead of the 2020 elections. Outside of politically driven instability another important risk is of terrorist attack. Attacks in early 2016 in neighbouring Burkina Faso by Islamist extremists brought the threat closer to home. Although the low incidence of sectarian tensions suggests that the country—even if not without disenchanted youngsters—is not an ideal breeding ground for radicalised aggressors, the porosity of its borders remains a cause for concern.
Ghana is not likely to be a central target for terrorists, but its close ties with the West and significant ex-patriate population in Accra may draw the attention of extremists.
The outcome is by no means a foregone conclusion, however, with the results likely to be close. The NPP will need to work hard to attract votes from outside its heartlands in central Ghana while maintaining internal unity. Meanwhile, the NDC will continue to enjoy strong support in the east and north of the country, owing to historical and tribal allegiances. Greater Accra, a historical swing state, will be a key battleground, and so tensions in this economic hub could disrupt business operations. The following national elections will then be due in 2020.
Whichever party wins in 2016 is expected to preside over an improving economic situation and this will bolster their support in 2020, making re-election the most likely outcome. However, Mr Mahama would be constitutionally barred from standing again if victorious in 2016, so the NDC could face a damaging internal battle to succeed him, which may play into the hands of the NPP. If Mr AkufoAddo is victorious in 2016, he would be eligible to stand again in 2020, but would be 76 years old by then and so could face challenges from inside his party.
Two people who allegedly robbed a Kaneshie-based forex bureau of GH¢ 150,000 at gun point have been remanded into lawful custody by an Accra Circuit Court.
Yakubu Alhassan and Haruna Abdulai aka Borbor have pleaded not guilty to conspiracy to commit crime and robbery.
An accomplice, known as Issah, is said to be on the run.
The Court presided over by Mr Aboagye Tandoh turned down a bail application put in by Mr C.K Hoeyi on behalf of Alhassan.
They are to reappear on April 13.
Prosecuting Chief Superintendent of Police Mr Duuti Tuaruka said Mr Bismark Boateng, the Managing Director of Bext Neasant Forex Bureau, is the complainant.
According to prosecution the forex bureau is located at Mpamprom, near Kansehie.
Mr Tuaruka said Alhassan is a welder residing at Agbogbloshie while Abdulai is unemployed and resides at Ashiaman.
On march 23, this year at about 1430hrs, Alhassan and Abdulai and two others now at large, went to the Forex Bureau under the pretext of conducting business and pulled locally manufactured pistols on complainant and two others.
According to prosecution the accused persons and their accomplices took the complainant and his two workers hostage and robbed them of both local and foreign currencies totalling GH¢ 150,000.
After robbing them, prosecution said one of the Forex Bureau staff raised an alarm and with the support from a Police Patrol Team from Kaneshie, Alhassan and Abdulai were apprehended while two of their accomplices escaped.
Before arresting Alhassan and Abdulai prosecution said the two fired indiscriminately at the people and as a result 14 persons were injured and they were rushed to the Police Hospital for treatment
Mr Tuaruka said due to the severe injuries sustained by Abdulai as a result of the mob attack he has not been able to give statement.
However Alhassan has admitted the offence in his caution statement and mentioned Abdulai and one Issah, who resides at James Town and another who he did not know his name, as accomplices.
Prosecution said GH¢ 58,000 have been retrieved from Alhassan and Abdulai as well as two locally manufactured pistols.
Ghana’s parliament would have to review the criteria for disbursement of the District Assemblies’ Common Fund, according to a professor with the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology (KNUST).
Government is mandated to allocate a proportion of collected national revenue to the local assemblies to drive development.
But land economist, Prof. Seth Opuni Asiamah, says conditions for selection and sharing of the common fund must be tied to the property rate collection potentials of each assembly.
“I don’t see, for example, why AMA, KMA and STMA should be paid huge sums of money from the district assemblies common fund when there are poor assemblies who cannot afford to execute development projects because the kind of revenue that they are collecting from property rate is so low; yet we give all the money to the big assemblies,” he stated.
Prof. Asiamah has observed that the Accra, Kumasi and Secondi-Takoradi Metropolitan Assemblies have huge opportunities to generate revenue from property rate collection.
He was speaking in an interview on the sideline of a symposium in Kumasi on the value of commercial properties and the effect on doing business in Ghana, organized by the Good Governance Africa (GGA) – West African Centre, an independent research and advocacy organization.
The event was on the theme: “Towards Improved Revenue Generation in Ghana: The Role of the Development and Use of Commercial Properties in Ghana”.
According to Prof. Asiama, cities and towns are not developing at a faster pace because assemblies receive cheap money from the Common Fund, hence fail to be proactive in property rate collection.
He is also advocating taxation on idle lands to compel people to develop their lands “rather than leaving them idle and creaming off profits when the value has increased and just have to sell them”.
Head of Land Economy Department at the KNUST, Jonathan Ayitey, says the real estate industry has huge capital potentials yet to be tapped.
He identified and categorized commercial properties in Ghana and the key drivers of rents and rates for commercial properties in urban settlements in Ghana.
Participants commended GGA for providing the platform to enlighten the public on the opportunities and challenges in the sector, especially in rent charges.
Chief Executive of GGA-West Africa, Tina Asante-Apeatu, says outcomes of the engagement will be put into policy papers to drive national planning.
Ahead of the World Autism Day, April 2, 2016, the winners of the 2014 Tigo Digital Change-makers competition, Alice Amoako and Solomon Avemegah, have announced the launch of their new innovation, an Autism Aid App.
It is the first of its kind in Ghana, and will create awareness, support communication among persons living with autism and assist parents and caregivers.
The free app can be downloaded from the Google Play store. It has three main features; a Picture Exchange Communication System that helps children living with autism to improve on their communication skills, an awareness platform which provides information on autism and an SMS Helpline that connects parents and caregivers to doctors and other health professionals with several years of experience in caring for children with autism.
Speaking about the app, the elated Alice Amoako and Solomon Avemegah, reiterated that it is a dream come true project.
“This project started as an idea. We had a lot of enthusiasm and hope that one day we will be able to make an impactful contribution to caring for persons living with autism. With expert guidance and funding from Tigo Ghana, this idea has now become a reality. We are grateful to the entire Tigo team for supporting our dream”.
The Director for Corporate Affairs at Tigo, Gifty Bingley, said Tigo remains committed to leading the digital lifestyle among Ghanaians.
“With partnership from International NGO, Reach for Change, our Digital Change-makers competition supports young entrepreneurs to champion digital excellence”.
The App will be demonstrated live for parents, care givers and volunteers to understand how it works. There will also be a free health screening for persons with autism.
The launch of the App forms part of the celebrations of the World Autism Day which begins with a walk at 8am on April 2, 2016.
It starts from the Efua Sutherland Children’s Park through the principal streets of Sankara to Osu, the Koala lane and back to the Efua Sutherland Children’s Park.
Key sponsor for the event is Tigo Ghana, with support from the Royal Bank, Vitamilk, Martha Ankomah Foundation, Accra Ridge Church, Special Ice mineral water, Ebern security, and the Ghana Telecom University College.
After several years of volunteering at the Autism Society of Ghana, Alice and Solomon, then students of the Ghana Telecom University thought about an Autism App and entered the 2014 Tigo Digital Change-makers competition.
They became the eventual winners and received the prize money of GH¢ 60,000. They were mentored by the Director for Technology and Innovation at the Grameen Foundation, David Hutchful.
The Ghana Independent Broadcasters Association [GIBA] has offered its support for the clamp down on cable television channels broadcasting in the country without the appropriate licence.
GIBA explained it does not condone piracy in the broadcasting industry hence its decision to support the National Communication Authority in the exercise which saw nine channels stopped from televising programmes Wednesday.
According to the NCA, the nine channels – Obinim TV, ATV, Clive TV, ECN, Zoe TV, BTA, Care TV, Kessben TV, and Elijah TV- violated Section 2(4) of the Electronic Communications Act 2008, Act 775.
It requires anyone intending to operate a broadcasting system or a broadcasting service to acquire a frequency authorisation from the NCA before such venture.
Commenting on the issue on Onua 95.1FM, President of GIBA, Akwasi Agyeman, Mr. Agyeman underscored the need for all broadcasting laws to be adhered to, adding “we urged the NCA to ensure that every one adhere to the authorizations”
He refuted reports that Obinim TV was taken off-air as a result of the recent condemnable utterances of the eccentric owner, Pastor Daniel Obinim.
There have been reports linking the shutdown of the television station to the actions and comments of Pastor Obinim some of which were in direct attack of some pastors and individuals.
But Mr Agyemang said those reports are unfounded, noting that the shutdown has nothing to do with Pastor Obinim except the failure to satisfy the licencing requirements of the NCA.
Ghana coach Avram Grant says he withdraws the use of the word ‘b*****t and explained what he meant with that remark.
The Israeli had told Ghanaians to focus on ‘the football, not the b*****t’ after a Nations Cup qualifying win. The remarks came after several weeks when his regular trips abroad had been roundly criticised.
But he claims he simply didn’t come across well and insist he has utmost respect for Ghana and Ghanaians.
“I withdraw this word. I love Ghana, I respect Ghanaians. I care about Ghanaians,” he told GFA Communications Director Ibrahim Sannie.
” What I wanted to say is that we need to focus on the important things that can take us forward and not about the unnecessary things.”
Grant’s withdrawal and explanation is unlikely to pacify those who say that comment highlights the Israeli’s disrespect for Ghana and want a full apology for that.
The Progressive People’s Party (PPP) has called on the Electoral Commission of Ghana to come clear on its relationship with Israeli firm Superlock Technologies Limited (STL), Ghana.
According to the party, the recent revelation by Minister of Interior Prosper Douglas Bani that STL transmitted results of the 2012 elections is a direct contrast to what the EC has put out about the company.
“This is because, the EC had publicly denied the fact that STL was contracted to tally the results of 2012 elections,” a statement issued on Wednesday, March 30 said.
Signed by PPP’s National Secretary Murtala Mohammed, the statement said the EC’s silence will mean that it “perpetrated a fraudulent explanation on us all when it was alleged that the STL was engaged in the transmission of results in the run up to the declaration of results in the 2012 elections.
“This clarification by the EC will have direct effect on our elections come November 7, when we go to the polls once again.
“The Progressive People’s Party demand immediate clarification on this matter in order to salvage the credibility or sanctity of the 2016 elections.”
The statement issued by the second largest opposition party was in relation to the deportation of the three suspected terrorists from South Africa.
The ex-police officers were detained by the Bureau of National Investigations (BNI) but later released and sent back to their home country though legal processes had been initiated against them.
“We further call for the immediate resignation of the Minister of Interior and the Minister of Communications and his deputy for the spread of palpable falsehood laced with agitprop with the intention to deceive the people of Ghana.
“Moreover, the BNI officials must be sacked or made to face the full rigours of the law.
“Our Ministers and other Government officials must learn to act responsibly and be responsible for their actions. No man is above the law especially when you are paid with the public purse.”
Ghana earned more than $900million from the oil and gas industry in 2014, a report on the operations of the extractive industry has revealed.
However, an amount of $84,382,088 could not be accounted for as government could not verify receiving such revenue from the oil and gas companies, the report added.
The report, which was prepared by the Ghana Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (GHEITI), assessed government’s revenue stream in the oil and gas industry and the disbursement of revenue into the various sectors of the economy.
The report blamed Anadarko WCTP Limited for failing to make the payments of the oil and gas revenue to the state.
“With the exception of Anadarko WCTP Limited, all oil and gas companies that made payments in 2014 reported to the GHEITI,” the report said.
In 2014, “a total of 37,201,691 barrels (BBLS) of crude oil and 55,758.04 Million Standard Cubic Feet (MMSCF) of natural gas was produced from the Jubilee field. Also, 79,602 barrels of crude oil was produced from the Saltpond field. This brought total crude oil produced in the country to 37,281,293 BBLS” the report indicated.
The sector’s contribution to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) slowed from 8.2% in the 2013 to 7.25% in 2014, this was still below the 7.7% contribution from the sector to the GDP in 2012.
The report, however, called for more transparency on the part of government and the various oil and gas companies operating in the country with regards to providing information on the performance of the Ghana petroleum funds (GPF) and the crude oil lifting, respectively.
It said though Section(1)c of the Petroleum Revenue Management Act 815 states that the “Investment Advisory Committee shall develop for the Minister of Finance as part of the investment guidelines, the benchmark portfolio, the desired returns from and the associated risks of the GPF and subsequently the Ghana Petroleum Wealth Fund taking into consideration the investment guidelines used by the Bank of Ghana for investments of a similar nature,” no benchmark returns have been developed by the Investment Advisory Committee and the BOG measurement on the performance of the funds were not consistent of Act 815.
It, therefore, called for the establishment of the investment guide to effectively monitor the performances of the GPF.
Also, the report called on the minister to provide detailed information on the stages of implementation of the various developmental projects funded by the Annual Budget Funding Amount (ABFA).
The ABFA is a predetermined percentage of the Benchmark Revenue but the actual allocation is determined by the Minister of Finance and approved by Parliament.
Currently, the ABFA covers four key priority areas namely, Roads and other infrastructure, agriculture modernization, expenditure and amortization of loans for oil and gas infrastructure, and capacity building including oil and gas.
You may remember the lyrics of Celine Dion’s “A New Day Has Come”
let the rain come down and wash away my tears
let it fill my soul and drown my fears…
After last week’s morning downpour, the rains only came down to unveil our shame. The indiscriminate dumping of waste in some parts of Accra has just gotten out of control.
This image was shot at Sodom and Gomorra in Accra.
According to a resident, the situation gets worse when it rains. Funny or sad as it may be, he was about to defecate there when I met him. Realizing that I had rudely interrupted his ‘business’, he asked that I quickly take the shots and go.
Gutters at the Kwame Nkrumah Circle in Accra
Surprisingly, 70% of waste management in the country is handled by the private sector while government agencies handle 30%. The private sector is assumed to be more proficient, and yet the problem keeps escalating. The Environmental Service Providers Association, ESPA, is an association of waste management companies that provides solid and liquid waste management services in Ghana.
In an interview with the Executive Secretary of ESPA, Ama A. Ofori-Antwi, she stated that continuous education, attitudinal change and the enforcement of the sanitation bylaws is the first step at resolving the issue. She also complained that the country lacked adequate landfill sites.
She said it is about time every household separated their garbage before they are disposed off.
The shores of Chorkor in Accra
In conversation with Kojo, a colleague journalist who happens to have lived in London for several years, stressed that there is no way he or anybody would drop garbage on the streets of London.
But in Ghana he does. Why? because no one cares. So it is not surprising to see foreigners throw garbage on the streets, whilst they would not dare do same in their home countries.
It’s this attitude that destroys a nation. If everyone disposed of their garbage properly – in designated bins or took their garbage home -, surely Accra would be as clean as our villages.
The public sector frequently get the backlash but, clearly, they cannot solve this problem of waste management if every citizen does not get involved.
After all sanitation is a shared responsibility, play your part!
“What were they thinking?” My colleague exclaimed as we drove home from work one tiring Thursday evening, through Osu Kuku Hill in Accra.
“Oh,’let me extend my wall into the pedestrian walkway; this is Ghana, no one cares’, could that be what they were thinking?” bemused Sammy wondered.
The Principal Road Safety Engineer at Urban Roads, Pat Onny , in an interview with TV3 Online, said prospective house owners are bounded by law to present to the local assembly their architectural drawings for a permit. This, she explained, is to ensure that an applicant’s drawing conforms to the building codes and standards.
She also stated that persons who construct their walls close to any street are supposed to leave a minimum distance of 1.5 to 2 meters to serve as a pedestrian walkway.
According to Pat Onye, the Assemblies should have building inspectors whose duty is to monitor and stop projects that flout the laws.
Unfortunately, the Assemblies have been handicapped by the lack of vehicles and other essential equipment. In other words, they are ill-equipped to do the job effectively.
“We have no love for this country and so we fail to see our individual responsibility towards Ghana. We blame everything on our leaders and play political gimmicks!”my colleague observed and I totally agree.
Another building that has left very little space for the pedestrian walkway.
A traffic prone area like Osu RE has few pedestrian walkways.
Some shop owners transcend the walkway to make the streets extension of their shops
Pedestrians are forced to share the road with vehicles
Some shops use pedestrian walkways as car park
Very few roads in Osu have appropriate walkways where even disabled persons can also move freely. Sixty per cent of deaths on the roads in Accra are pedestrian-related, 23 per cent constituted children of school going age, according statistics from the National Road Safety Commission.
Pedestrian safety is an issue that needs to be addressed immediately. Shop owners, homeowners who blatantly disregard the laws and build on walkways should face the rigorous weight of the law.
Unfortunately, the law regarding pedestrian walkways has deliberately been ignored, which many accept as a norm.
According to the head of communications of the National Road Safety Commission, Kwame Koduah, Statistics of pedestrian knockdowns in 2015 stood at 2,121. This staggering figure could have been reduced if road safety rules and regulation were simply enforced.
Deputy communications director of the New Patriotic Party Perry Okudzeto says the handling of the 3 ex South African police officers who were arrested last week, is a clear indication of a desperate administration clutching on straws to retain power.
The three men who were arrested in the Central Region for allegedly engaging in activities with national security implications were deported on Tuesday.
They were put on board South African Airways flight number 210, which departed around 9:26 to Johannesburg
Speaking on 3FM’s midday news, Perry Okudzeto described the handling of the situation as.
“We woke up one morning in this country and we had newspaper headlines screaming that mercenaries had been brought into our country and that their presence here was of a national security concern to the extent that the state owned daily graphic displayed the photographs of these people on their front page.
“Beyond that, these men were arrested on Sunday, a week ago, kept for more than 48 hours before their lawyers were allowed to see them.
“They were finally charged on Thursday which is clearly 4-5 days after they were arrested which is a violation of our laws as a country.
“They were sent to court and whiles in court a judge in a court of competent jurisdiction granted them bail and what did we see after they were granted bail; the security agencies bundled them into a vehicle and drove off the court premises instead of handing them over to the court clerk for the necessary documentation to be done or processed for their bail.
“They were then kept beyond the Easter holidays and to wake up on Tuesday morning after Easter to hear that these people have been deported and their visas revoked.
“This tells you clearly that this is a government that is clutching on straws and clearly a government desperate to retain power.
“After bringing in terrorists from Guantanamo Bay into this country and keeping them here and telling us to show compassion, you turn around and arrest people who have been law enforcement officers in another country for about 19 years on the average.
“The government and the security agencies should be ashamed of themselves”.
The FBI has managed to unlock the iPhone of the San Bernardino gunman without Apple’s help, ending a court case, the US justice department says.
Apple had been resisting a court order issued last month requiring the firm to write new software to allow officials to access Syed Rizwan Farook’s phone.
But officials on Monday said that it had been accessed independently and asked for the order to be withdrawn.
Farook and his wife killed 14 people in San Bernardino in December.
They were later shot dead by police. US officials said Farook’s wife, Tashfeen Malik, pledged allegiance to the so-called Islamic State on social media on the day of the shooting.
Last week, prosecutors said “an outside party” had demonstrated a possible way of unlocking the iPhone without the need to seek Apple’s help.
A court hearing with Apple was postponed at the request of the justice department, while it investigated new ways of accessing the phone.
At the time, Apple said it did not know how to gain access, and said it hoped that the government would share with them any vulnerabilities of the iPhone that might come to light.
On Monday a statement by Eileen Decker, the top federal prosecutor in California, said investigators had received the help of “a third party”, but did not specify who that was.
Investigators had “a solemn commitment to the victims of the San Bernardino shooting”, she said.
“It remains a priority for the government to ensure that law enforcement can obtain crucial digital information to protect national security and public safety, either with co-operation from relevant parties, or through the court system when co-operation fails,” the statement added.
Responding to the move, Apple said: “From the beginning, we objected to the FBI’s demand that Apple build a backdoor into the iPhone because we believed it was wrong and would set a dangerous precedent. As a result of the government’s dismissal, neither of these occurred. This case should never have been brought.”
The company said it would “continue to increase the security of our products as the threats and attacks on our data become more frequent and more sophisticated”.
An Israeli newspaper last week reported that data forensics experts at cybersecurity firm Cellebrite, which has its headquarters in Israel, are involved in the case.
Cellebrite told the BBC that it works with the FBI but would not say more.
Its website, however, states that one of its tools can extract and decode data from the iPhone 5C, the model in question, among other locked handsets.
The court order had led to a vigorous debate over privacy, with Apple receiving support from other tech giants including Google, Microsoft, and Facebook.
FBI director James Comey said it was the “hardest question” he had tackled in his job.
However, he said, law enforcement saved lives, rescued children and prevented terror attacks using search warrants that gave it access to information on mobile phones.